REMAKE -- CASTING?


My main thought for a remake of this movie is that it would be a perfect vehicle for George Clooney. Mr. Clooney is very reminiscent of old Hollywood and I think that he would make a perfect choice to play Macdonald Walling, the part played by William Holden.

I may be alone in my wish that today's stars and movie studios would cease churning out endless (and sometimes ridiculously silly) sequels of popular movies and remake older movies that people of today's generation don't know and probably never heard of. There are so many movies, main event and B-movies (and even serials/chapters), that there are endless possibilities.

reply

I just watched this film, and think all the performances are spot on perfect, that to remake it would be pointless. William Holden and Fredric March are truly brilliant. Barbara Stanwyck, Walter Pidgeon, Paul Douglas, and Nina Foch were also excellent. I wouldn't change one thing.


"Tessie" is the Royal Rooters rally cry.
"Tessie" is the tune they always sung.

reply

[deleted]

Hi, FilmSon!

Couldn't agree with you more -- no remake needed here.

Anyway, think about it -- no explosions, no FX, no monsters -- who'd ever want to remake a serious drama?

Though I would be curious about updating the financial figures in the film by 53 years!

But good news -- see my new post re the DVD!

reply

[deleted]

Well, of course, "All the King's Men" is political, which gives one a reason for remaking it...but the new version is terrible -- as remakes often are.

An "Executive Suite" remake would certainly never have a noble company being led by a noble, far-sighted leader, at least not as in the original. They'd throw some Enron-type situations in there, make everything much more jaded and cynical. That's why I'm fascinated by the choice of Oliver Stone to do commentary on the DVD of "E.S." -- I guess they figured his experience on Wall Street (both in real life and in the movie) made him the appropriate choice!

reply

[deleted]

It's a shame they don't try to record commentaries or at least separate interviews with directors, actors, and so on for films as yet unreleased on DVD, but in anticipation of their eventual release, before such people pass away. TCM's brief interviews, such as the one you mention with Nina Foch, at least go some way toward that end. But they act as if these people will last forever. The more time that passes, the quicker such film greats pass, as the dual losses of Shelley & June in 2006 (and Lehman and Wise in 2005) showed.

But besides Nina, Tim Considine is, as you might guess, still with us, even working, with a film appearance this year. Same with William Phipps, now 85 but also working at least up to a few years ago. But pretty much everyone else seems gone. The IMDb board has no birth/death info on Lucille Knoch, who played Caswell's girlfriend and was in some other 50s films; no credits past the late 50s; still, she might still be alive. Also a woman named Faith Geer, who played the hat check girl at the Stork Club; for some reason I clicked her on and while there are again no birth/death dates, her credit list shows her bit in ES, then nothing until the late 80s, when she began turning up in several films and TV shows, into the early 2000s. According to this list, her second film upon her return after a 34-year absence was none other than "Wall Street". I'll have to check that out. A connection with O. Stone, perchance? Doubt it, but an odd coincidence, especially given the paucity of her film career.

By the way, I'd forgotten but the newsstand guy whom Caswell grabs the papers from before getting into his cab is Gus Schilling, who you may remember played the headwaiter at Dorothy Comingore's night club in "Citizen Kane". His career apparently spiraled down into bits and small parts, but I guess both Orson Welles and John Houseman remembered their old Mercury Theatre player and gave him some work, Houseman in ES and Welles in 1958's "Touch of Evil", which Schilling worked on before his death of a heart attack in 1957, just four days before his 49th birthday.

See you later, and thanks for your great posts, as always.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Yes. I posted a thread on this site marking that sad event, as Miss Foch was also Executive Suite's only Oscar nominee.

Harry Shannon was not the only Citizen Kane alumnus in ES. Gus Schilling, who played the headwaiter at Susan Alexander Kane's night club, was the newsstand vendor from whom George Caswell grabs the papers outside his office building before taking the cab to the Stork Club. ("Journal, Post and Telegram" are the papers he got -- from the good old days of multiple newspapers in NYC and the country. Only the Post, such as it is, remains.)

And, of course, director Robert Wise was the film editor on Kane, and producer John Houseman, while not directly involved with CK, was with Orson Welles for a number of years in the Mercury Theatre. Good movie genes.

But Tim Considine is still around, as is William Phipps, who played Bill, William Holden's assistant in the development shop at Tredway.

reply

Some movies should never be remade; this is one of them!

reply

Well, of course, you're absolutely right in the first place. Leave well enough alone. A remake would be pointless and undoubtedly vastly different from (and inferior to) the original story.

reply

Exactly, instead of a remake, maybe Hollywood needs to find a way to introduce these gems to a new generation (or three). Perhaps theatres could have an entire program of 'oldies but goodies'... at a set day/time so that those interested don't have to search to find them; or give them the star treatment and a rerelease like they did when I was a kid (in theatres for a limited time!), but include a build up with trailers and PR and build excitement.

reply

Executive Suite was done as a television series in 1976-1977. The only castmembers familiar to me were Ricardo Montalban, Joanna Barnes, and Lloyd Bochner. The names of the characters were changed.

The series, like the film, was based on the novel, Executive Suite, by Cameron Hawley.

Lloyd Bochner may be recalled as having acted in a well known episode of The Twilight Zone, To Serve Man.

The series was very popular in Ireland. But it was cancelled there in mid-season. That was because one of the characters was considering having an abortion. The Irish Catholic Church put pressure on Ireland's network to have it pulled from the schedule.

reply

[deleted]

If they remade this today they'd have Leonardo DiCaprio in the Holden part and his big speech at the end would be his vision an eco-friendly company making tables from recycyled paper to save the rain forests. It would be an absolute and unmitigated disaster. In the 50s and earlier they made movies for grown-ups, now they're made for the young and everything has to be simplistic, black and white, or, in DiCaprio's case, a bilious shade of green.

reply

Why does it seem that nearly EVERY thread on a remake starts off with someone flogging George Clooney as the lead? Does he pay people to post such things?

George Clooney, on his best day, MIGHT have been talented enough to fetch coffee for the cast of this movie. William Holden could out-charm, out-rage, out-suave, and out-act Mr. Clooney even today...and he's been dead for over 30 years.

No, it doesn't need to be remade. We have it on DVD and can watch it anytime we want.

reply



Every board of almost every classic film has someone post a re-make comment. I'm glad this one got the disdain it deserves. We don't want no stinking remakes!

reply

Amen! No remakes!!

reply

I thought Walling was supposed to be young? Clooney is old now and frankly not a very good actor to give that last monologue. Walling should be in his 30s.



Global Warming, it's a personal decision innit? - Nigel Tufnel

reply

Problem is you would need for the movie to take place in China with a Chinese cast. American manufacturing and American Industrial Pride are gone.

reply