Kind of depressing


While I love the movie I can't help but find it a little depressing. The two main characters spend the day together and fall in love and then at the end they go their separate ways.

reply

I like to think they eventually reunited. There's a post somewhere on this board about how a sequel was almost made (much later, if I recall correctly) where they got back together.

A lot of people believe Roman Holiday was the remake of Princess O'Rourke (1943) with Olivia de Havilland, in which there was a happier ending http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0036277/


Mag, Darling, you're being a bore.

reply

[deleted]

Neither do I. I may be a bit desensitized to the ending from seeing it so many times, but the movie always cheers me up. There's nothing not to love about Audrey Hepburn in Rome.

reply

[deleted]

It ends like that to make you feel "more". Life aint so simple. Besides, you can write your own ending. Maybe she called him a week, a year, or more later.

reply

It has an uncliched ending but boy did those final scenes feel padded.

Its that man again!!

reply

I thought the final scenes were just right; not too rushed, not too slow. The princess didn't want to leave Joe or this thing called a normal life and he didn't want her to leave. Many viewers understood how hard it was for them to part and to attempt to go back to the way their lives were before they met.

Back to the OP again: It doesn't have to be depressing to know that they all got to spend a fun day together. Ann won't always have to wonder what a normal life may have been like.


Mag, Darling, you're being a bore.

reply

I try to imagine that from her perspective, it was an unexpected once-in-a-lifetime experience unlike anything she had ever experienced, and never expected to, a memory of which she would cherish in memory forever. Women in her station don't usually have the luxury of gallivanting around Paris anonymously and falling in love with a good, not to mention sexy, man whose heart was touched by the experience and did not betray her, as so many would do. So I think she was viewed the wonderful day as a rare gift, even though she always knew it could only be for one day. I think the fact that the ending is so bittersweet adds to the overall beauty of the movie.

Life is a banquet, and most poor suckers are starving to death!

reply

Forget Paris! It was Rome. What movie were you watching?

reply

Forget Paris! It was Rome. What movie were you watching?
LOL! A Roman holiday in Paris! And now for something completely different!🐭

reply

Movies nowadays don't have the balls to go for bittersweet endings. All contemporary romantic comedies end with sugary sweet, silly, contrived happy endings.

They couldn't be together. They knew. It was painful, but they parted ways. These kinds of encounters are much more common and easy to relate to than the happily ever after films we're being spoon fed now...

reply

The ending left me feeling slightly depressed as well. However, I think it was to the movie's benefit to not have it end in typical cliche hollywood romantic comedy fashion. Made the story resonate a little more, for me at least.

reply

Agreed. I was expecting she would run behind him.

reply

It is not a simple happy ending that's for sure
*SPOILERS*



But, she got to live a small dream of hers and also mature, accept her destiny and responsibility as a princess, and take control of her situation.
She also got the relief and confirmation of not having her secret day revealed which confirmed the feelings were mutual and real.
He discovered something honorable and pure in himself too by not writing the story. And he got his own confirmation of how she felt about him.

It's a real ending. They both got to feel something real but also had to sacrifice.
It's sad but for 24 hours in their lives they got the memories of a lifetime.
It's really one of the better endings I have ever seen in a film. It perfectly captured all the thrill and torture that love can be.

reply

[deleted]

Great points, JPLogan54! That 24 hours will enrich their lives for a lifetime.


Mag, Darling, you're being a bore.

reply

I watched this for the first time recently, expecting it to be charming, but predictable. I was very pleased with the story taking a different turn than I expected and ending the way it did. This was a great film and one that I'm disappointed I didn't watch sooner.









Trailer For My Second Feature
https://youtu.be/UXsIq-oPxXA

reply

I must confess to approaching the movie with a bit of trepidation, even given it's classic status and pleasingly finding myself not being disappointed. Granted, by today's standards the film's plot may be a tad generic but it is more than made up for with Dalton Trumbo's winning screenplay and the superb, charming performances from it's two leads. The movie's denouement I think is about as close to perfect as one could hope for, with the subtle nuances in their body language, visual glances and verbal exchanges making for an emotively palpable lead up to a poignant, heart-felt finale.

I don't know if the film is depressing although there is a tinge of melancholy but to some extent it's uplifting as well. Both protagonists have both been less than satisfied with their lot in life and having found one one another their life inextricably changes, arguably for the better. She becomes a better princess by forgoing protocol and adopting change while he becomes less cynical and has a slightly less self-centred perspective on life and has learned to love in a way he never knew how, and perhaps someday he will again. It's a magnificent pay off and one that sublimely forgo's convention with class and dignity.

reply

[deleted]