MovieChat Forums > The Robe (1953) Discussion > The first Caligula flipped out

The first Caligula flipped out


On the blu-ray documentary for The Robe, Jay Robinson mentioned how an actor named John Buckmaster was cast as Caligula. After they were a third into the movie, Buckmaster flipped out on the set. He was screaming, ripping off his toga, and they had to call the police. So they replaced him with Jay Robinson. I tried to look up John Buckmaster. The only information I have was that he was Gladys Cooper's son. There's no information on him. He also went on to have no career. I can't find any information on the details to why he went crazy on the set or what exactly happened. It's very mysterious. If anyone has more information on this, please let me know.

reply

That interview with Robinson is on my non-blu ray documentary, as well. They were two months into shooting when Robinson had to audition a scene with Jean Simmons. It was his first audition and, when it was over, there was applause on the set. Robinson says that he believed all were being polite and that this was customary after an actor auditioned. Simmons told him how extraordinary it was and it was then that he realized he may have landed the role.

Demetrius and The Gladiators began to shoot three weeks after The Robe wrapped and the very opening scene to The Robe was actually lifted from its sequel - though I believe mention of this is made here, in the trivia section.

The devil turns away from a closed door.

reply

In February 1952 Gladys’ son John was arrested by police in Manhattan after violent conduct emanating from his mental illness. Gladys found it difficult to accept that it was a long-term illness that John had, expecting him to make some kind of recovery. But John was put into the Bellevue Hospital for the Criminally Insane in New York only to be later released following his agreement to leave the United States for good, which he did in 1952. John was then kept in a clinic in England where he spent his latter years, but he refused to see either Gladys or his father Buck, blaming them for his breakdowns.
http://www.gladyscooper.com/Biography/Biography.html


"The trick is to not mind the pain."

reply

As I recall, Buckmaster got involved with Vivien Leigh when she was going through severe mental problems. Probably not the best companion for her under the circumstances. I think Stewart Granger mentioned him in his autobiography when he talks about confronting a naked and deranged Viv and says something about Buckmaster being around.

reply

DryToast, thank you for the information. This is him, right:

http://www.whosdatedwho.com/celebrity/photos/john-buckmaster.htm

I wonder how he would've been as Caligula. I heard they were a third of the way through the movie. I wonder if he filmed any scenes. For all we know, he might've been great as Caligula. After all, he was insane in real life. His performance might've been pretty realistic. He might've been better than Jay Robinson. Jay was great, but sometimes he overacted.

reply

But John was put into the Bellevue Hospital for the Criminally Insane in New York only to be later released following his agreement to leave the United States for good, which he did in 1952.


So how is that he was cast in the role and, presumably, returned to the US to film The Robe in Hollywood?

The devil turns away from a closed door.

reply

I'm not sure. But I know they carted him away when he was filming The Robe. On the set, he went mad, started tearing off his toga, and they called the police. I like Jay Robinson, but sometimes he overacts. I understand he was young when he filmed The Robe and Demetrius and the Gladiators. But he did not look young. Caligula was a young man when he died. They pretty much got it right in Demetrius and the Gladiators how that idiot turned his own praetorian guard against him and they murdered him. Never mess with the guys protecting you.

Based on what DryToast posted, it looks like I'm right about how they tried to cover it up. The guy is practically buried. John Buckman would never be known as the first Caligula if not for Jay Robinson. Nobody will ever know his story. But I think it would make an interesting movie.

reply

I'm sure his mother was deeply mortified and kept the entire affair under wraps until the day she died - or he died, whoever died first.

The devil turns away from a closed door.

reply

There's no date of death on IMDB, but if he's still alive he's 95. Yes, they certainly did keep it under wraps. Obviously they were ashamed. A guy that was set to play Caligula in The Robe, a huge motion picture epic, had a nervous breakdown, was committed, and never heard from again. Sad story. If they picked him for The Robe, he must've showed a lot of promise as an actor.

reply