MovieChat Forums > The Secret Garden (1949) Discussion > This and the 1993 version are excellent

This and the 1993 version are excellent


In my comments on the 1993 version I had said that I'd seen the old 1952 version apprently it was this one. This is a great old-fasioned classic.

reply

The acting is great in most versions, but the great visual style of the 1993 version makes it the best.

reply

this film is so marvellous, i perfer this one to the 1993 one, you fell in love with o'brian as mary, the 1993 one irrated the hell out of me

Thunderbirds Aren't Slow

reply

Really, I liked the old one better then when the Hallmark one came out I liked it better but it really was bad - the girl had a southern US accent. I liked the 1993 one best - what was annoying about it - the way Mary was so bratty? She was supposed to be from the book, I believe.

reply

[deleted]