MovieChat Forums > Key Largo (1948) Discussion > Anybody else think at first Gaye was pla...

Anybody else think at first Gaye was played by Barbara Billingsly?


Kinda' freaked me out seeing her virtual clone act so coarsely. I mean she looked more like June Cleaver than June Cleaver. Had to check the cast on INDB to my amazement she wasn't.

reply

I did too. I realized shortly after it wasn't her, but at first I was pleasantly surprised to see her in it.

What's next? Prostitutes rising from the ground and spitting all over my lawn?

reply

That's who she reminded of! I spent the whole movie trying to figure out the old-school actress I was trying to think of...

reply

Now HERE'S a bunch of classic film fans!

reply

No I'm afraid not I knew it was Claire Trevor because she's been in 2 other movies with Bogart before in the late 30's in Dead End & The Amazing Dr. Clitterhouse. Sorry Mrs. Cleaver.

reply

They are lookalikes that I've never noticed before. I thought Claire Trevor looked different in this. Mostly age-wise. Perhaps they made her up to look a bit older in this one.

reply