Femme fatale....exam!


Hey, you guys all seem to know quite a bit about film noir so I wonder if you could help me...
I'm studying the postman always rings twice for my a level media research paper which is on Friday. I'm focussing on the femme fatale character and comparing the 46 version with the 81 version. It's basically do your own research, so if you guys had any comments about Cora it would be really useful, whether you have seen one or both of the versions anything will help! Be critical, give a feminist point of veiw..whatever you think.
Cheers!

reply

I LOVE the 46 version and i dont plan on watching the newer one b/c im afraid it'll ruin one od the best movies ever made. Seeing as how i am not a woman it'll be a bit diffucult to give a feminist veiw, but i'll give it a try. For starters Lana Turner was probably the most beautiful woman of "old hollywood" and it's pretty unanimous that she looked the best she ever did in this role as Cora. She always had bad intentions and you can't expect John Garfield not to fall for her, so when he does she uses it to get away from her husband she didnt love anyway. But what i really liked, was the way that she was so fickle she loved him, then she turned him in, then she hated him, then when they were off the hook she loved him again then it went downhill for her, in one of the best endings ever.

reply

Yeah I agree, she really uses her sexuality to manipulate Frank in the 46 version by being so hot&cold, which doesn't really happen in the 81 version probably because it wasn't so much about feminism. And she is gorgeous in it! Thanks for taking the time to reply, it'll be a big help! Cheers.

reply

Hey whenever you finish your paper let me know how you did

reply

Check out this...

http://members.aol.com/MG4273/garnett.htm#Postman

GREAT analysis, looks at the feminist aspect and compares it to the working man/business man relationship.

My thoughts on Cora:

First off, Lana Turner is one of the worst actors of old Hollywood, and the platinum blonde hair/white wardrobe makes her character even more unbelievable. But belive it or not, these two qualities make this a great film noir, adding to the enormous pulp atmosphere (in fact, it IS the pulp atmosphere, as there are few noir visuals, like expressionistic shadows), and keeping us in mind that this is from John Garfield's perspective, not necessarily how it happened.

This also is a unique noir for two purposes: it tries its hardest to make the femme fatale and her lover sympathetic, and yet they kill an innocent man. Its the precursor post-60's protagonist, in which it was OK for them to murder (and now they were free of the production code that required them to be punished).

Not to say that Cora isn't as femme fatale as Phyllis Dietrichson in Double Indemnity. SHE controls Garfield's relationship, she rises above oppression through powerful means (murder), and is manipulative and seductive. She's a great example of how the femme fatale uses her sexuality to convince a man to do what she wants.

reply

cheers all for you help! the exam went ok I think & your comments were all really useful..thanks again!

reply

Hey I just saw this board, but I'm guessing your exam is over now lol. So how did it go? I'm curious now!

"A toast to Success!"
"Yours or mine?"

reply

[deleted]