MovieChat Forums > The Picture of Dorian Gray (1945) Discussion > Better if we never saw the picture at al...

Better if we never saw the picture at all?


Just saw this on TCM recently and found myself freaked out by the picture when we didn't know what it was starting to look like. That is until I saw the garish technicolor rendering that was supposed to be shocking. While definitely unpleasant I no longer found the picture horrifying. I felt like it was a bit of an anticlimax and shown much too soon. I'd much rather have had a lot longer without seeing the picture but the suspense building as something horrible is emerging in my imagination.

Or maybe even better would be never to see it at all. This to me is the greatest advantage the novel has over the movie. In never being able to physically see the picture, the novel's reader must paint for themselves its corrupted and ruined visage and that is something that each of us makes out of the stuff of his own worst nightmares. It doesn't get any scarier than that.

reply

Every film version of this I've ever seen shows the painting at several stages of Dorian's corruption. I think that seeing this is essential to our understanding of what this does psychologically to him.

He puts the painting away in a locked room as much to escape from seeing it as to protect the big secret.


The Fabio Principle: Puffy shirts look best on men who look even better without them.

reply

I agree and what made my heart jump was the music! Right at the moment we see it, it gets real loud! Wow.

Wait! Wait! Where are you going? I was gonna make Espresso!

reply

It scared the shit out of me as a kid. Now though the portrait in this film anyway is kind of comical and over the top. I think something a little more realistic yet still evil or deformed in some way would have been more effective.

reply

No. I love the painting. And the decision to show it in color at times was brilliant. It truly shocked me. A great motion picture. I had no idea what to expect with this film.

reply

No, I think you need some kind of pay-off.

reply

To me, the reveal was the best part!

reply