MovieChat Forums > The Uninvited (1944) Discussion > Just saw this...who buys a house with th...

Just saw this...who buys a house with their sibling?


Just saw this for the first time and immediatly wondered who would buy a house with their brother/sister.

I unfortunatly was very tired watching it so the end twist really didn't register with me. I'll have to watch it again. From what I saw, it was both creepy and funny, very entertaining.

Nuke the whales! (Gotta nuke somethin')

reply

You have to remember when this movie was made/took place. Roderick was a batchelor, his sister a spinster ("normal" marriage age.) it is post-war, and gentlemen back then took care of their families. (She mentions that both parents are dead, right?) He would be obligated to take care of his sister, and she would, in turn have a place to live, and her 'job' would be taking care of him - in the ways of housekeeping, doing laundry, light gardening, etc. My bet would be even if she didn't end up with the doctor that she would live in the house with Roderick and Stella after they got rid of the ghosts.

It's just the way things were done in those days - and BTW, it still happens now. Families combine, and take care of each other. I know personally, my aging mother and I ended up sharing a 1800 sq foot ranch house because she couldn't handle it by herself, and it was cheaper to live there than sell the house and looking for an assisted living facility. She was 20 years into a 30 year 1971 mortgage. This was back in 1992. And on the same subject, a friend of mine who is a youngish grandmother (she married early and so did her daughter) is now taking care of two three-and-six-year-old nieces because their mother is a total screw-up and the aunt that was taking care of them died of a freak asthama attack.

There is another thread on this board that covers the same question - you might want to look for it...

reply

[deleted]

Yep, buying a house with a sibling is still a frequent practice even today, although it may be more common in certain regions (and in certain cultures) over others. If you're both adults but still unmarried, I see no reason for siblings not to pool their finances and buy a joint property to share in the meantime. Even if you both are married, many still often do it, although in the US, people seem to require more "personal space." I grew up in the "the Deep South" and it's not uncommon to have 2-3 generations living under the same roof. My neighbors are Portuguese immigrants and their extended family (grandparents, children, grandchildren) all live together as well.

reply

Roderick wasn't taking care of Pamela. They pooled their money to buy the house.

reply

Who buys a house with their sibling? Apparently my dad does - just bought a cabin with my aunt.

So yeah.

It's only a movie, and, after all, we're all grossly overpaid - Alfred Hitchcock

reply

I think we will be seeing more and more of this practice come back.

People simply cannot qualify now (most of them) for a decent property alone.

When I say a 'decent' property, I'm thinking of actual land; to plant on, fence in to keep the children safe (I miss the days of wandering the CA canyons until dark, with no fear), a big enough house to give whoever in the family needs shelter, and allow some privacy as we get used to sharing housing again.

Or maybe rent out a room if times get really tough.

The whole outlandishly apart zoning we've never thought about works against us now. For commuting to a job, running errands, even just...slipping to the store for one forgotten thing for dinner.

Now many people walk a fair distance for health; we're getting used to that, but I see a lot more 'listing' and 'stocking' and pantries coming back. With gas so expensive, delivery services are great, but once again, it helps to split the cost with someone else.

It's getting a bit better, but we've set ourselves up as a generation-apart, neighbor-stranger, drive everywhere society in many parts of the country.

I don't think we really meant to do it. We just got sold on the idea.

It's made auto and oil companies very rich, and allowed for many neighborhoods to fall into disrepair and stay that way. We just move away and start over.

We can't anymore. We've got to work with what we've got, and that, by the way, would give construction companies enough work for the next - forever, as they remodeled, added-on, and rebuilt all the housing we have.

reply

Facepalm. I thought they were husband and wife the whole time, and was rather scratching my head at the romance brewing between Ray Milland and the other girl. Especially the final kiss in front of the guy's 'wife'.

But yeah: an extremely effective/creepy and enjoyable movie. :)

--- grethiwha -------- My Favourite Films:
http://www.imdb.com/list/Bw65XZIpkH8/

reply

The William sisters...

reply