Hawks/Huston


Never really could get into Casablanca due to the coldness of characters and a story I couldn't believe (But that's me). Just loved the warm interplay between Bogart, Brennan and Bacall that Hawks handled well in To Have and Have Not. The script has a few ironic humor laughs, and the closing scene is really great to watch as Bacall shimmies out the door (a daring touch). Houston could never do that. Remember the look on Mary Astor's face when she was standing in the elevator being lead away to prison in the last scene in The Maltese Falcon? Cold, cold, cold (as it should have been). Hawks seems to get more out of character interplay than Huston. Hawks' wonderful Cary Grant, Jean Arthur, Thomas Mitchell classic Only Angels Have Wings confirms this. When it comes to telling an action tale without getting too deeply into characterization, Huston shines. When I watch The Treasure of the Sierra Madre or The Maltese Falcon the raw action is thrilling (They're no brainers). The point is that Hawks plays characterization whereas Huston plays story. Remember, Bogart was 45 years old and Bacall was about 20. It's a credit to Hawks' directorial skill, and Bacalls and Bogarts talent that they pulled off this story successfully. I love both Hawks and Huston for different reasons.

reply

Hawks had already directed great romance comedies such as "His Girl Friday", "Ball of Fire", so I think he was really good at creating the chemistry by dialogues and wits. But was he also good at getting deep into characters' inner world? I doubt. To me, Bogart's role in this movie seems more shallow than Rick in "Casablanca" or Dobbs in "The Treasure of the Sierra Madre". Hawks Probably just didn't prefer tragic or bittersweet story, which usually, IMO, were bad for box office but good for getting deeper into characterization.

reply

At the end of To Have and Have Not, I was sorry to see the three characters go off and wished to join them. I did not want to join the characters at the end of The Maltese Falcon and Casablanca.

"Two more swords and I'll be Queen of the Monkey People." Roseanne

reply

yeah, i like this film and bogies work with huston more then i liked casablanca.

reply

That is a good point that Huston liked the story, Hawks liked the people. Hawks liked Lauren Bacall, too, ended up briefly with Dolores Moran instead.

"Two more swords and I'll be Queen of the Monkey People." Roseanne

reply