MovieChat Forums > A Guy Named Joe (1944) Discussion > Irene Dunne at her dramatic best

Irene Dunne at her dramatic best


Irene Dunne never made a poor movie. Indeed, I find her to be the finest actress, in either drama or comedy (at which she excelled) to never win the Academy Award. She should have. Several times over she should have.

In "A Guy Named Joe" Irene Dunne does several things that remind me of her greatness:

1. She holds her own with the best, Spenser Tracy. She would do so as well with Carey Grant and with William Powell. But here, she perfectly matches the great performance by Tracy and by Van Johnson.

2. She exhibits the perfect instincts, timing and use of eyes and facial responses to establish the authenticity of the character and the moment and intensify the emotive response of the viewer.

3. Her piloting the fighter in taking on the Japanese ammunition depot, with the departed Spenser Tracy in the back seat, is unforgettable. Holly Hunter in Speilberg's remake cannot match the intensity of the moment, not only for the mere acting ability, but also for the times. Imagine, a woman piloting a fighter, becoming a WWII heroine, taking on an enemy in the midst of exploding shells and detonating bombs, and flying, confidently through the smoke and debris to successfully bring the ship home and secure the victory. It cannot truly be compared to the modern version of the film It stands alone as does Dunne's performance of this first for women in film.

4. Her beauty, a sort of Midwestern, all-American girl beauty, is every present. She plays a character in the same way as Jimmy Stewart plays a character: with ease and believability and likability. Like Stewart, she leaves you feeling good, and she leaves you wanting more.

Get the movie. Bring the whole family together to watch it. And enjoy Irene Dunne at her dramatic best. Then go out and get "My Favorite Wife" to see how she so easily transitions into a comedic role with the same powerful effect on the viewer.

reply

[deleted]


Also, Irene Dunne was 18 years older than Van Johnson, and although you can tell she is older, it doesn't interfere with the love relationship between them. I kept looking for signs of Van Johnson's accident that left him with a metal plate in his head and caused the movie to be put on hold until he healed... but you couldn't tell at all.

Comparing Irene's performance to Holly Hunter's in Always, well they have different acting styles so I didn't have an issue. Also, I'm a pilot for almost 39 years now, and there's no way in heck I'd EVER fly through a forest fire or while being shot at... so I have no idea how I would portray that emotional experience... hmmm, well now that I really think about it, Holly Hunter's scene flying through the fire WAS more intense... gee I love her too... she's a very sexual woman, Ms. Holly... Irene Dunne was not that sexually intense but of course if she had been, the movie would have been censored.

Come to think of it, I DO like Always better, but I prefer Van Johnson to the young pilot in Always.

We sure do live in a great age! While many of the newer movies are cr*pola there are still good (current) gems and lots of great (older) gems... what did we do before TCM?? I have no idea and I will also really miss what'shisface (the tcm host) when he kicks off.

Life is a journey not a destination. Fear nothing.

reply