Somewhere in the world


there must be a copy of the original unedited version with the non-musical ending.Not the one that everone has seen since it original release in 1941.

reply

Why would you want a version without "Aurora"? That's a great song, one of the best ever covered by the Sisters.

If I could drop dead right now, I'd be the happiest man alive.

reply


I completely agree. I'm not a real big fan of the musical numbers in their films--most of them are bland, unmemorable and bring things to a screeching halt--but I liked "Aurora" the first time I heard it and I never tire of it. It fits in well with the story and the sisters do it perfectly. Definitely a keeper.




The beatings will continue until morale improves.



reply

There was not a version without the musical ending. The Andrews Sisters were added to the film BEFORE its original release.

reply

The film was completed in February 1941 . In May 1941 there were new scenes added , and reshoots done .

reply

The scenes you're talking about were never in any released version of the film. Virtually every movie's production includes shooting a fair amount of footage that never makes it into the the theatrical release. This isn't any different from any of those others. In that era studios weren't in the habit of keeping the edited-out-of-the-movie bits of film around. They tended to recycle it for the silver content.

Heck, there are Pre-Code movies for which we don't even have the actual theatrical release version because the studios didn't keep anything besides the final, final cut. If a movie was popular enough to warrant a theatrical re-release several years later (after the Code was being enforced), the bits that no longer passed the censors were thrown out; and the studios wouldn't even keep *one* copy of the original theatrical version. The only reason that we have the theatrical release version of King Kong (which was an absolutely iconic blockbuster) is that one of the editors took one set of the cut out bits home, and some decades later they were found in his garage.


So, to answer your original question:

No, it's not a given that there is still a copy of that footage anywhere in the world. It's possible that there's one somewhere; most of the previously-lost footage from Metropolis turned up just a few years ago. Realistically, though, at this point I have to figure that the odds are against any edited-out sequences of Hold That Ghost being discovered.

reply

I've always said I would like to see the original cut , not the released version .

reply