MovieChat Forums > The Ghost Train (1945) Discussion > So I've got to ask ... (spoilers)

So I've got to ask ... (spoilers)


... why didn't they just send the bus straight away instead of trying to scare everyone? The driver could've told them the station master was able to organise one after all. There would have been no need for Julia and John Price to show their faces, no need for any play acting, and the travellers would've been out of the station quick smart.

I loved this little film so I'm hoping that someone can come up with a good reason.

*
Last seen: Bees in Paradise (1944) 4/10

reply

Scooby Doo logic. They had to maintain the 'legend' to keep people away permanently and erase any curiosity anybody in the long run may have.

As I don't care for football or MTV awards, I'm watching Ghost Train now. I prefer it on cold weekends, but it's hot now, but I'll compromise.

reply

I think the mindset was to scare them away, even if it sent them scurrying over the hillside in the rain, an unlikely scenario, but these seven people in the station were the least of their concerns.

Once it became apparent they weren't just going to be scared away, not by the ghost conductor or the crazed sister and her brother, then they arranged to get the bus there.

This was during war time, everything was rationed, especially petrol, so if they could scare these people into leaving under their own steam, that would save them the fuel.

I've just rewatched it and noticed how convenient things played out, especially with the sister; the door opening when she said she could see the old conductor or stationmaster, whatever he was, and likewise when she asked which door the conductor had previously entered, it was necessary for the fellow to mention the fellow entering the door.

I think the smugglers didn't count on the guy having a gun. By then, he knew it wasn't merely an unexplained phenomena, like Nessie.

I also wondered how much of a hiccup was the bridesmaid dropping her package and items in the way of the brother's car, sending him off the road.

Perhaps he was going to give them all a lift out of there in his car (would be terribly crowded, I think).

reply

Scooby Doo logic. They had to maintain the 'legend' to keep people away permanently and erase any curiosity anybody in the long run may have.

Of course!! I'm an idiot, thank you 

This was during war time, everything was rationed, especially petrol, so if they could scare these people into leaving under their own steam, that would save them the fuel.

That's a very nice observation. If a bus full of petrol had immediately arrived for no good reason, the 1940s audience would have probably had something to say about it.

As for the finer plot points you mention, it's been so long since I've seen the film, I'm afraid I can't comment. I've no memory of them at all.

Thanks again.

*
Last seen: Blue Ruin (2013) 8/10

reply

There's an 'original' uploaded to youtube, but with a sequence out of order.

I do so enjoy the '40 version, tho.

reply

Thank you, I'll give it a look, although I think was probably Arthur Askey who really sold this one to me. When he's on top form (Back-Room Boy (1942) is another good) he can slay me with an aside, one of the few comedians who can make me burst out laughing.

*
Last seen: Trainwreck (2015) 6/10

reply

I suppose these are plausible enough. Still I liked the film even without an explanation.

Poorly Lived and Poorly Died, Poorly Buried and No One Cried

reply