MovieChat Forums > Fantasia (1941) Discussion > Question About Possibly Higher Audio Qua...

Question About Possibly Higher Audio Quality


So, I'm something of an audiophile, but not enough of one to answer this question on my own. Others, feel free to chime in.

According to Fantasia's Wikipedia article...

...Link here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantasia_%281940_film%29 ...

...in 1955, the original sound negative (which had begun to deteriorate) was transferred via telephone wires onto magnetic tape. All subsequent audio remixes, remasters, and re-releases have been based on that, rather than the original sound negative.

So, my question is this--if the original negative had been preserved, would it have been possible to repair, restore, remaster, and upgrade the audio quality of Fantasia's soundtrack to an even higher audio quality than it's available in today? I ask because I was under the impression that magnetic tape is an inherently worse (though not necessarily terrible)-sounding source of audio than an audio's original negative recording.

That's assuming, of course, that I understand things correctly, which I may not. But had the original negative been preserved, rather than transferred onto magnetic tape, might it have been possible to get even better audio quality out of Fantasia's soundtrack?

"I apologize for my rantings--they are induced by red-bull binges."
----Stephen Colbert

reply

Yes, my idea is it would have been better to return to the original negatives, if they had been preserved.

These were the original multitrack recordings, which means they could have made a stereo remix from each individually recorded group of instruments, much like engineers have gone back to the multitrack recording session tapes of The Beatles and The Beach Boys from the Sixties, rather than the sometimes rather poorly mixed two-track stereo masters used to cut the LPs.

If you read the Wikipedia entry on Fantasound and elsewhere, the 1955 copy suffered from being transferred through telephone wires, which caused the loss of the highest frequencies - less treble.

Dicky






reply

What a shame too, because the 1957 LP 3-disc set was based on that telephone-wire master.

If they had just made a soundtrack LP a few years sooner...

reply