MovieChat Forums > You Can't Take It with You (1938) Discussion > The xylophone playing brother in law ???...

The xylophone playing brother in law ????



Does anyone recognize who this was? I saw this guy on so many
movies playing the old southern gent, or redneck, as the case
may be, and I cannot find any hint of what his character's name
was or who he is. A very distinctive voice and character actor.

Any ideas, or even what the character's name was?

reply

How'd you miss it? His name in the movie is Ed Carmichael, played by Dub Taylor.

reply

Wow that was fast, thanks. Somehow I missed his name.
I saw this movie in the theater yesterday and the sound
was kind of muddy. I remember that guy all the while
I was growing up in TV shows always playing a bad guy.

reply

You're welcome.

The theater, eh? I wish they'd show it in the theater here, they could use a little culture.

reply

In Palo Alto CA there is an old movie theater downtown called the Stanford theater.
http://www.stanfordtheatre.org/stf/
It opened in 1925 and played most of the old movies that it now replays.
Tickets are $7 and the shows are always double features. I have seen so many old movie that I had never seen on the silver screen or otherwise. Most of them are as good as or better than the new movies that come out now.

reply

That is just too awesome. I looked at the site--how cool! I want an old movie theater in my town!!

reply

If Dub didn't know how to play the Xylophone-we may of never of known the actor.....when casting,knowing your way around a xylophone was a Requirement

reply

That was a vibraphone (also known as a vibraharp) - not a xylophone.

reply

Well, if you are going to play Mr. Know-it-all, can you please go all the way and explain the difference?

reply

Well, if you are going to play Mr. Know-it-all, can you please go all the way and explain the difference?



I looked it up, apparently there IS a difference, xylophone's become a generic term for all the similar instruments in the percussion family, but xylophones are supposed to be wooden, and vibraphones are aluminum metal.

reply

So ... a vibraphone is a type of xylophone ... so I am not wrong, right ?

reply

It's like saying "a banjo is a type of guitar"... you would not be entirely wrong, still they are two different instruments.

A xylophone is rather small, with wooden bars.

A vibraphone is big, with metallic bars, and an electric device underneath that makes the sound vibrate.

The mallets are different too: hard for the xylophone, soft for the vibraphone.

reply