Interesting, as I always noticed the resemblance, but doubtful.
A couple of things....Muni was a huge star over at Warners, and his 'type' was 'he didn't have a type'. Muni was their prestige "I can play anything" actor, complete with heavy make-up. Early in his career, if there was a model for Paul Muni, the closest one would be Chaney Sr, without the emphasis on horror. Quite frankly, Chaney was considered a brilliant character actor as well, although his legacy emphasizes his horror roles.
Anyways, I doubt they were asking for Muni or a "Muni Type" for "Dracula's Daughter". I doubt it was ever mentioned or considered.
BTW, Irving Pichel is little known today, but he was in fact, very busy in the early days of film. He usually played 'ethnic heavies', even co starred with Tallulah Bankhead in one film. He was apparently quite an artistic talent: went to Harvard, was good friends with George s Kaufman, and spent the bulk of his post acting career directing, with a fair level of success.
Long story short? Pichel wasn't considered 'second tier' in his day, and they knew what they were getting with him.
It's amazing some folks carved out solid careers, but never had the big hit putting them in the permanent fame category.
Pichel is certainly one of them.
reply
share