MovieChat Forums > The Public Enemy (1931) Discussion > Great Cagney. Film influenced Scorsese.

Great Cagney. Film influenced Scorsese.


Scorsese says on the DVD that he loves this movie and it is quite evident that it helped form his film style. In this movie there are many things that resonate in Scorsese’s films. One that I saw immediately was when Tom kills Putty nose; it reminded me so much of when Tommy killed Stacks in Goodfellas. They both kill then exit speaking to who else is there in casual conversation as if it never happened. There are also other details that show up in scorsese's films that pay homage to other great gangster movies of old.

Also, Cagney was amazing in this film. He acted so naturally compared to the rest of the cast. He slouched on couches, he moved like a shark, changed the way the dialogue was said, he changed his facial expressions as other actors talked, improvised body language and actually looked like someone who walked of the street. The rest of the cast were really weak and their performances did nothing for the movie. He began modern film acting with this picture. Great film and a great actor.

I really like this movie; it gets better with every watch.


Brando is King
Eastwood is cool
De niro is Badass

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I thought The Godfather was good, but was too romantic. The Second part was much, much better. By the way, Cagney was excellent in this. Much, much better than the usual performances you see in early talkies.

reply

[deleted]

Are you kidding me? Scorsese's gangster films were all about the grittiness and realism of the gangster life, in complete contrast to films like The Godfather and De Palma's Scarface. Mean Streets was all about the life of low-level hoods trying to live the gangster lifestyle. Goodfellas, too, brilliantly depicted the romantic side to the Gangster lifestyle and then contrasted it with the total ugliness and vulgarity of their actions.

I agree that many of the earlier ganster films influenced De Palma too but to deny their impact on Scorsese's work is a little silly!

reply

Definitely silly. I thought Scorsese was renowned for disliking The Godfather anyway? He was already making films when it came out anyway.

reply

It's one of my favorite films too, primarily because of Cagney. He's very natural compared to the other actors, many of whom are very stiff.

I would love to hear Scorsese's thoughts on The Public Enemy. I'm not surprised that he was influenced by films such as this one.

"Dry your eyes baby, it's out of character."

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

i was suprised at how well the film looked and how well it's aged. i was impressed.

reply