MovieChat Forums > All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) Discussion > Is this the movie where....The horses ar...

Is this the movie where....The horses are killed?


I just got back from the I Need To Know boards asking about this haunting scene where a soldier is screaming to shoot the horses. Was it this movie? It always bothered me cause it was disturbing, but I forgot about it...

reply

I just ordered (rented) the DVD from Netflix. I'll let you know once I've viewed it.

I don't know what's a sig. line? Can't think of one! Can you tell me what one is?

reply

Unfortunately, I found-out that their version is 130 minutes so I hope the horse scene (if it is indeed in this film) isn't deleted.

I don't know what's a sig. line? Can't think of one! Can you tell me what one is?

reply

I'm in the process of watching it and will continue sometime later today.

I don't know what's a sig. line? Can't think of one! Can you tell me what one is?

reply

I just finished watching it on DVD from Netflix and unfortunately that scene wasn't in it. However, that doesn't mean it isn't AQotWF as the DVD was only 130 minutes (2h, 10m) and there are longer versions which might (or might not) have the horse scene in them, or not.

I don't know what's a sig. line? Can't think of one! Can you tell me what one is?

reply

Hello! Thank you so much for your time and updating on me. It's too bad it wasn't the same flick and I would think it would be this film since it sounded so similar. The clip I saw was very brief and during a documentary. It was so strange, perhaps it'll show up again one day on TCM or some other. But again can't thank you enough, that was awesome of you and I appreciate it :)!
*edit* Also thank you for finding me on I Need To Know
I did call it solved or at least concluded the search because this film also looks good.

reply

I'm watching the 1979 version right now (for the first time) and it has the scene you mentioned.

Never be complete.

reply

Really??? It was such a long time ago but apparently struck me. Thank you! Its one of those movies I forgot about and then saw another film that reminded me.

reply