MovieChat Forums > The General (1927) Discussion > DVD...Why Two Different Lengths?

DVD...Why Two Different Lengths?


I picked up two cheapie-DVD versions of this movie from Walmart and Best Buy recently...and they have different running times. One of them is 107 minutes (GoodTimes DVD) and the other is 78 minutes (Quality Special Products).

Where do those variations in length come from?

reply

Chances are they're projected at different speeds. If the GoodTimes version was recorded at 16 f.p.s. [frames per second] or thereabouts, and the Q.S.P. version at 24 f.p.s., that could account for the difference in running times, especially if the Q.S.P. version has been trimmed of a scene or two.

Have you viewed them yet? Does one seem to move noticeably faster than the other?

reply

I just screened the first couple minutes of the shorter one, having watched the longer one in its entirety yesterday.

It did not seem to be moving any faster; it moved at the same natural speed. If it had moved faster, everyone would have been moving unnaturally fast. I did notice that they cut off the opening credits, that the picture quality was substantially poorer than the Best Buy (GoodTimes) version (which put the entire movie on one DVD side to itself instead of sharing space with another, and probably used a better film print), and the music was some scratchy old phonograph jazz recording instead of the classical music to which the Best Buy (GoodTimes) version was tracked.

One thing I noticed while checking the versions in the IMDB listing for the movie is that there were apparently different-length versions of the film, but it maddeningly doesn't go into any detail about what was cut and why. Was hoping to find some answers to that here. I really don't want to have to watch the whole short-length one to find out. If I have to watch the whole thing over again, I think I'll watch the one with the better picture quality.

reply