strange light


I think there are two shots in which the prisoners turn around and look towards a light which shines on them. Why? How now?
Should that mean, that somebody is entering the cell? Or is there any symbolic meaning?

reply

hello?

reply

It's Jesus Christ, of course.

-J. Theakston
The Silent Photoplayer
http://www.thephotoplayer.com/

reply

in the jail?

why do they look so scared?

reply

If Jesus showed up at your house suddenly, wouldn't it kind of freak you out?

reply

*looool*

sure, but why is jesus there in the jail? he doesn´t say anything.

reply

He doesn't have to. His appearance says it all.
This film is a "Tale of the Christ", remember?

In earlier films up to the fifties, I think, it was a problem to show Jesus Christ. For Protestants it was forbidden to make or look upon any visual representations of the biblical figures, and even Catholics had problems with the 'holiest' of them, like God and Jesus. So when Jesus entered a picture, we experience him only indirectly.
When in the sixties Jesus was finally represented in his own movies (by Jeffrey Hunter or Max von Sydow), for some this was still an unholy act.




"When there is no more room in the oven,
the Bread will walk the earth."

reply

When you have to explain subtlety to some people all may be lost.

reply

This is just a side-note, but I do understand your comment; however, I am delighted to see that an appreciation for this film exists in this generation. As I tell my students, "If you have a question, ask it. Don't worry if others think you are stupid, as others are wondering the same".

You ought to apologize to the O.P.

"I love corn!"

reply

"If Jesus showed up at your house suddenly, wouldn't it kind of freak you out?"

I'd also be freaked if the Spring Equinox Bunny showed up!

reply

Having read the novel and seen both film versions several times, I have to say that I do not believe that the Christ visited Miriam and Tirzah in prison. My reasons:
1.) Miriam and Tirzah do not hear of the Christ until Esther tells them of Him while they are in the Valley of the Lepers.
2.) Miriam and Tirzah do not meet the Christ until, in the novel, on Palm Sunday; in both movie versions, during the Way of the Cross.
3.) Mother and daughter are healed of their leporsy either on Palm Sunday (the novel) or on the day of the Crucifixion (the movies). If the Christ had visited them in the cell, why didn't He heal them of the disease then?
The novel shows one scene with Miriam and Tirzah in prison, listening to the calls to prayer from the Temple and praying on their own, waiting for their deliverence form prison. I believe the scene referred to is an attempt to show the two in prison, to show what happened to them during the years that Judah was in Rome. The lighting effect was probably unintentional, considering the harsh lighting needed for film at that time. The fear on their faces can be ascribed to their life in prison. Think about it: innocently locked in prison without a trial, the sounds of insane prisoners and the screams of the tortured all around them, never knowing what would happen to them next. I think anyone would react with fear at the slightest noise.

Although it was a custom in Hollywood to only show the Christ from the back, it was not due to any religious custom or tenet. It was merely to give a sense of religious aura to the scenes. Although Protestant beliefs were often against theatre, the Catholic church has used theatre as a teaching tool for over a thousand years. In passion plays, music dramas, and English cycle plays Christ was portrayed by an actor and there was no complaint from the Church. Rather, it was supported. D.W. Griffith's "Intolerance", made in 1916, showed Christ from the front. More importantly, Cecil B. DeMille's 1927 "The King of Kings," (which was "The Passion of the Christ" of its day) not only showed Christ from the front, but also has close ups of His facial expressions. While showing Christ only from the back was a convention, it was not universally followed, nor supported by, at least, the Roman Catholic church. (I am both a Catholic and a theatre teacher. I could give you more examples and even dates to support my argument, but they don't belong here.)

Sorry to ramble on so.
Spin

reply

Just before that, there is a decree that all prisoners whose crimes are unrecorded will be set free. They are in darkened cells, so a fully opened door lets in light, signifying their freedom.

They are being allowed to leave the prison though they still are outcasts. Later, Christ heals them. Christ is not at the prison.

*** The trouble with reality is there is no background music. ***

reply

Actually, he was in prison. Shoplifting. Very sad.











The 2,000 year old man told me.

reply