MovieChat Forums > Karen Gillan Discussion > Just started watching her in Doctor Who

Just started watching her in Doctor Who

posted 10 years ago by w22nuschler
3 replies | jump to latest

I must say she is my favorite companion so far. She is beautiful, she has a great body, she is a very good actress and she has great chemistry with The Doctor.

Rose was just ok, as was her mother and boyfriend. Martha was really good but they did not give her enough good storylines. And Donna was plain awful until one of her last episodes, where she was Doctor Donna. I thought she was great in that moment. Too bad she was so bad the rest of the time.

[–] JohnVFerrigno 10 years ago

I actually loved Donna. She was so sassy and never took the Doctor's BS. I loved how funny she was. I thought they had great chemistry.

[–] glassyo 10 years ago

I grew to love Amy but Donna is hands down my favorite companion for all of the above and because she was compassionate and never had a thing for the Doctor. I'd already had enough with Rose.😃

What do we want?
Time travel!
When do we want it?
It's irrelevant!

[–] w22nuschler 10 years ago

I finished watching the Amy episodes and they let me down more often than not. I think I am ok with how they ended the story with Amy & Rory. At least they lived a long life and were together. I don't think I will ever totally understand everything that goes on in the Doctor Who world. I have read other complaints about trying to follow this series.

I really wanted to love this show, but it's been more of a hit and miss for me. I am halfway thru Capaldi and Colemand and I feel the same way. I do like the way The Doctor and Clara work off each other. They have a different chemistry than the other Doctors and Companions. The Christmas show they did was my favorite story of any episode that I have seen so far. Hopefully the classic series will be better for me.