Why the law suit?


Before I ask my question, I have to say to that I was and still am a fan of P.W.'s movies. I was saddened to hear about his death and then stunned and horrified to hear that he died in such a horrible crash.

That being said, I still have a question: why has the family been forced to sue? Yes, it's true the crash was horrible but didn't P.W. specialize in these high end supercars with his partner who perished? The average guy can't just buy a car like this...These are specialized racing cars designed by porsche.

If the car had multiple previous owners, that's a sign something's not right - and porsche would have to know this too.

I would think Porsche would just quietly settle. Why make this situation a public spectacle hurting future sales, why force the family to sue, why prolong closure for the family AND the fans?

Or is this a classic case of power conceding nothing without a struggle? Porsche has $$$millions and they're not giving it up without a fight - even if it is a case of being wrong. : (

reply

I would think Porsche would just quietly settleWhy would Porsche settle when the car was being operated too fast under conditions?

The speed limit on the road was 45 MPH. The Porsche was traveling significantly higher than 45 MPH, in some reports, double the speed.

The lawsuit is frivolous.

reply

Nobody is forcing the family to sue, and why would Porsche want to settle for any reason, let alone to bring closure to family and fans? If the family and fans want closure then they need to accept that the reason for the deaths were nothing but idiocy and running into a light post at around 90 mph, double the speed limit, and catching a few trees after that impact.

Hopefully the judge makes quick work of this lawsuit and rules that the plaintiff pay Porsche all legal costs and more for wasting their time.

reply

The family was not forced to sue. Paul Walker's daughter, Meadow, is the one who brought the suit. Now Roger Rodas widow sued Porsche and lost in September of last year. The judge in that case stated that Roda's widow failed to plead her case that the Carrera GT should be equipped with “more extensive crash safety features than typical road cars because racecars operate at extremely high speeds and drivers routinely maneuver in risky ways, resulting in higher occurrences of both crashes generally and of severe crashes. But the judge also ruled that she had cognizable claims for design defects, relating to “the suspension component, the crash cage, and the fuel cell,” and those causes of action for liability will proceed in litigation. Meadow Walker's lawsuit states that "the vehicle lacked safety features that are found on well-designed racing cars or even Porsche's least expensive road cars -- features that could have prevented the accident or, at a minimum, allowed Paul Walker to survive the crash." The court document contends the 2005 Carrera GT should have come with an electronic stability control system to protect against swerving. The car also lacked adequate side door reinforcement bars and had defective rubber fuel lines, according to the lawsuit. There also seems to be a dispute about the speed of the vehicle at the time of the crash. The initial report that I heard put the speed at 80 to 93 miles an hour. The coroners report put the speed at about 100 miles an hour. The family's investigators put the speed between 40 and 60 miles an hour. At this point take your pick. I guess we'll have to see what happens with this lawsuit, but I could have told anybody that there were going to be lawsuits concerning these deaths. If you ever get a chance to read about this particular car you will see what I mean. The car has a funky history and the way it is described is bit confusing. Go to a website called Road and Track.com. It gives you some idea about the car and how it was built. What I've gotten out of it was that it was race car for the road, but when you read about the way it handled you are kind of scratching your head a little bit. That might be why Porsche keeps getting sued. I don't know and its just a tragedy all the way around.

reply

They're kidding themselves if they think that car was only going 40 to 60 miles per hour

reply

They're just trying to cash in on reckless driving
His acting was a joke too bad about his death but that's what happens when you mess around

BHT RISES myspace.com/blackheart60

reply

And it was modified.

Ich bin kein ausgeklügelt Buch, ich bin ein Mensch mit seinem Widerspruch.
Conrad Ferdinand Meyer

reply

Porsche didn't settle - Rojas estate settled - the judge dismissed the suit against Porsche - his estate made the mistake of admitting liability

reply

The op is a complete moron. Multiple owners mean nothing with exotic cars. Many are bought and sold for investment purposes. I hope Porsche does not lose this frivolous lawsuit. It's not their fault someone was illegally speeding on the street and lost control.

reply