MovieChat Forums > Michael Haneke Discussion > No posts for this guy.

No posts for this guy.


Put some respek on his name.

reply

I've seen two of his films so far, The Piano Teacher and Benny's Video, and neither of which have truly impressed me. You can tell he's a guy with a lot of things he's aching to say, I just don't agree with the way he tells his stories. He shoots everything in a long, master shot and while it works for some scenes (such as in the incredibly uncomfortable sex scenes in The Piano Teacher), he does it far too often. His movies often come off as though they're slow just for the sake of being slow.

On top of that, I find the guy very pretentious and unlikable in interviews. He seems to always want to say something that just breathes wisdom and intellect, but a lot of what he says just comes off as airy, pseudo-intellectual bullshit to me. His famous quote "a feature film is twenty-four lies per second", I'm still not sure do I entirely get (it's about how film is an artifice that ultimately reveals truths about the human condition beneath its superficiality in each frame, right?). By comparison, Kubrick managed to sound much more intelligent while never delving into such vague, abstract nonsense (and of course, was a better filmmaker too).

reply

Found both of those films compelling among others.

reply

Yeah, I thought The Piano Teacher was all right. It was told in that typically slow, tedious way he likes to tell stories, but the character Isabelle Huppert portrayed was actually fascinating and her actions throughout the film are definitely worth a deeper study of. It's really Benny's Video that failed to grab me in any way.

reply

Huppert was phenomenal. Watched several of her movies after The Piano Teacher. White Material (2009) and Elle (2016) are good ones that come to mind.

reply

Although I like both of those films, he's done better. Funny Games, The Seventh Continent and Amour are all great movies.

reply

He should do a marvel. Gonna put him right on the map... haha.

reply