One of the best character actors out there.
Even in roles with little screen time like Looper or 12 Years a Slave, Dillahunt is one of the most believable actors in the industry. He first blew my mind on Deadwood when I realized he played both Francis Wolcott and Jack McCall -- two *vastly* different characters.
All of this to say that I think you're a shapeshifter, Garret Dillahunt, and the villagers are now gathering their torches and pitchforks.