MovieChat Forums > Shiri Appleby Discussion > Would of been the perfect Bella in Twili...

Would of been the perfect Bella in Twilight...


I can't stand Kristen as Bella in the movies. The character of Bella = Liz Parker....like they are the exact same character. In fact the whole story love story is exactly the same, except alien, not vampire. But I can totally picture Shiri playing Bella to perfection unlike Kristen who is just so not likeable.

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

and Shiri is far more attractive...

reply

i totally agree. shiri is amazing. and even though i like twilight, it really is basically a rip off of roswell.

reply

She is more attractive, and I love the sound of her voice. But, isn't she about 30 years old now? Too old now to play a high school student.

reply

She would've been, but she's far too old to play a high school student now.

Veronica Mars is smarter than me.

reply

Ya'll really need to make up your minds. First you say she looks TOO YOUNG to play the mother of a teen in "Life UnXpected" and now she's too old to play a teenager? What's it going to be?

If they needed a fecal 'transplant,' just feed 'em one of the "Grey's Anatomy" scripts.

reply

What's it going to be?

This could be a bit difficult for you to grasp, but a 30 year old can BOTH look too young to play a teen's mother and too old to play a teen. Not that I agree about Shiri looking too young for her character on LUX. I think she's aged plenty, and would thus look ridiculous playing a teen. Bella is something she could've pulled off 8-10 years ago.

reply