MovieChat Forums > Harvey Weinstein Discussion > ultimately i don't think this will chang...

ultimately i don't think this will change anything in Hollywood regarding the infamous casting couch.


I feel Harvey was stupid and his career is probably over, but he's still disgustingly rich. and i think the casting couch will remain for people who want to sleep their way to the top. Harvey messed up by HARASSING the actresses. i think there's a difference between casting couch and what Harvey did.

reply

Agreed pay for play will still be a big thing. HOWEVER I think it'll be easier for women to combat it now (if they so choose) thanks to social media and mainstream news media. I think the music industry will be a harder nut to crack because nobody really respect music artist the same as they do actors. The modeling industry is a grey area, i'm from that world.

reply

Grey area meaning what exactly?

reply

Meaning it's not under a microscope the same way mainstream film industry is.

reply

Is that why a lot of models are ugly. I've noticed that.

reply

I believe this is true, casting couches go both ways there are people that will offer themselves to get a leg up, it is up to the other party to resist because they in the end get the short end of the stick if it ever goes wrong. While I don't care for harassment, I also don't get to upset about it because its another one of those things that is often abused and not evenly enforced.

reply

If some ugly old woman said she would give me a job making millions of dollars a year if I would sleep with her I'd be like, "peel down baby."

reply

SAME! lol

reply

you shouldn't have to.

reply

He doesn't have to, he is choosing too. Inappropriate request by the old lady? sure. But he is free to say no and go on with his life.

reply


And yet...there is no job at the end : (

Only VD.
.

reply

But this doesn't happen as often in real life. That rich old lady along with any rich person already has gropies chasing them. They don't need you.

reply


<< That rich old lady along with any rich person already has gropies chasing them. They don't need you. >>

It is really weird that Mr. Weinstein seemed to hit on SO many women, indiscriminately! I mean, if artists want to date/sleep-with/marry these rich benefactors/employers/whatever, that's fine. But since there are plenty of starving artists in Hollywood, why did Mr. Weinstein have to just come on so strong to seemingly EVERYBODY?? It's very strange. Plenty of actresses/models would have called him up on their own!

I think he must be somewhat sadistic, and enjoyed cornering women he could tell didn't want him (?) That was probably part of the thrill for him...
.

reply

He came on soft but doesn't appear to be that he is not used to be being told no, at which point he came on harder cause he's not used to rejection most of us know to move on and invest in another girl but harvey is all about winning he never wants to loose so he ups the ante at that point its not even about the girl its about the perception that he was rejected. Hence the whole your embarrasing me dialog in the tapes. Notice that he initially tries to shew her away after being rejected bit then changes his attitude when he realizes he will be percieved as being rejected. Like he kept pleading with her not to embarass him in his hotel which he had been in for years. He may even have intended to just have her stay in the hotel for 5 minutes then see her off as if he rejected her or something. It could havbeen a ploy to get her in the room but I'm convinced it wasn't about the woman at that point.

I'm pretty sure there were plenty of starving artists. In fact I'm pretty sure there are some of the artists comming out now that did accept his advances back then but are now taking a stand against him as they still feel victimised. The dialog didn't sound like a sadist. Sadists usually start out charming and turn sadistic after they've formed a codependency bond with a low esteem woman. Don't get me wrong he may have had submissive women on the side but I don' see evidence of general sadism in the tapes. More like just a control artist.

reply

Hmmmm. I'm not a psychological expert, what you say may very well be true.

<< Hence the whole you're embarrasing me dialog in the tapes. >>

That did sound strange to me on the tape...like, how is she embarrasing him by refusing to go into his room? It's not like she's causing a scene....people talk in hallways all the time.

He's a weirdo. There are many kinds. He's going to come off as even worse if he fights his contract being broken, etc.
.

reply

For the narcissistic control type the thought of a woman publicly rejecting them drives these types of men crazy. I've seen this on the streets in one case a girl got shot in the face because she stood up to a man that was beating up his girlfriend. The man was used to controlling woman on the streets(Prostitutes) through drugs and the girl that stood up to him was one of his women. had she done this in private I'm sure she would have just gotton beat up. These type of men say stuff like "She's disrespecting me". This case sounds the same except that the man is a professional and punishes women through other means, these types of men are trying to be the ultimate alpha and any indication that they arn't getting what they want is considered embarrasing to other men which they view them selves as being superior to them.

reply

You forget the other half of the equation which is if you don't sleep with me, I will make sure your career is dead.

reply

You forgot that you don't get to the other half if you accept the first half.

reply


<< if you accept the first half. >>

But....there are NOT enough roles for all the actresses and models (and even non-professionals!) Mr. Weinstein offered them to. So, it's really not even a fair trade, as Hollywood doesn't even have that many roles for women to begin with. Let alone at one production company (Miramax).
.

reply

"But....there are NOT enough roles for all the actresses and models (and even non-professionals!) Mr. Weinstein offered them to. So, it's really not even a fair trade, as Hollywood doesn't even have that many roles for women to begin with. Let alone at one production company (Miramax)."

Which is why he was so easily able to control up comming actresses that were desperate and now hate them selves for accepting his advances. The women that rejected his advances were denied into entry level hollywood and no on is taking their claims seriously. Its only the artists that gave in that are famous enough to take an effective stand against him. At least they have taken a stand though more need to come forward.

reply


<< Its only the artists that gave in that are famous enough to take an effective stand against him. >>

I haven't read any complaints from women who "gave in" (haven't followed the evolving case THAT closely) except for the journalist he cornered and masturbated in front of.

SEE: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STWHSX8p3Vw

She said in one interview that she did question herself right after, thinking "Did I lead him on? Could I have got away?"

But I haven't seen other women discuss how encounters with him were really consensual.
.

reply

"I haven't read any complaints from women who "gave in" (haven't followed the evolving case THAT closely) except for the journalist he cornered and masturbated in front of. "

Its just a suspicion but I'm pretty sure the high name actresses that are comming forward with complaints but they are not being as forth comming with the details of the encounter. But I'm glad they are helping in the investigation. I don't think the journalist gave in. She had no reason too. Giving in would actually have hurt her if it ever got out.

reply

I hope its over
Pretty gross...
NO more of this shit...just make fun and smart movies...jeez!!

reply


<< just make fun and smart movies...jeez!! >>

One thing that's really (additionally) bad about this whole mess is Mr. Weinstein made some of the only classy, intelligent films in Hollywood. So...really, it's a bummer on THAT level he won't be working any more.
.

reply

Agreed!!! No lie...loved this guy
The guy had an eye for what a movie should look like/scripts that could work/stars that should be in them...
Harvey was a boss!
Fucking shame really...

reply


He worked closely with his brother, who's still around. Maybe Harvey was more of the frontman and Bob had the actual artistic taste.

Let's hope, anyway!
.

reply

"I feel Harvey was stupid and his career is probably over, but he's still disgustingly rich. and i think the casting couch will remain for people who want to sleep their way to the top. Harvey messed up by HARASSING the actresses. i think there's a difference between casting couch and what Harvey did. "

Yea i agree with this. It sucks but I think Holly wood will remain the place were a decent upcomming actress still won't be able to compete with another upcomming actress that is willing to spread her legs. And the second actress will actually feel empowered by her sexuality. Sex positive 3rd wave feminism has failed the first actress and yet benefits the powerful men in the industry.

reply

blaming sex positive feminism is intellectually lazy.

reply

You act like meat, people are gonna start treating you like meat. Intellectual laziness is thinking that emulating the worst behaviors of men the behaviors you claim to hate about men impowers your movement.

reply

I have no faith that the studios and major production companies have any real desire to clean house, to stop the abuses, or to make better working conditions for actors.

HOWEVER. I think there's a good possibility that investors will stop letting producers have such a good time on their dime, why should they invest in a film where someone's mistress is cast in the lead, instead of the best possible actress for that role? Financial motives are always stronger than moral ones.

reply

Youre probably right
I wont be shocked if he making films again in a year or two...short memories:/

reply