Has he ever been in a good movie?
I mean, I have nothing against him. He seems like a nice fella, who enjoys privacy (and I respect that).
But, I don't think I've ever seen him in a just remotely good movie. "She's all that" was a typical, pathetic attempt from Hollywood, to make some easy dollars. "Scooby-Doo" was a disaster. "Head Over Heels" was - again, pathetic. "Boys and Girls" made me wanna puke. The two "I know what you..."-movies were okay (when looking at the genre teenage-slasher), but not really something I would call good movies by any means.
I think that's why people are calling him such a bad actor. Maybe he is. I don't know. But what I know is, that until now I haven't been able to see him perform on a level, that could give a hint of which level he's at. He always go for the easy/not-really-need-to-perform roles, in *beep* movies. And I think that's sad.
All these voices in my head, and not a single one I understand.