Seminar
Surprised no one posted this yet. Doesn't Jerry O'Connell has rabid fan girls?
Anyway, he is in Seminar by Theresa Rebeck with Alan Rickman on Broadway and was very good! Played a very different role than we're used to seeing him in from just the movies and it was very entertaining. The show is recommended but I think it'll only be playing until 3/8/12 or so.