Better before eye was fixed
I thought it made him more alluring, more appealing, and more vulnerable.
Kind of like Forrester Whittaker. That man is huge and tough, yet I'll never take him seriously in a one dimensional role. His eye is so dominant and adds depth to his characters. I could say the same for Emma Roberts, I think her eye makes her even more attractive.
Then again, I've never had the eye problem, so maybe it was a pain he had to deal with every day. Who am I to judge?
Empty what is full. Fill what is empty. Scratch what itches.