MovieChat Forums > Annette Bening Discussion > Why is she more deserving than these oth...

Why is she more deserving than these other multiple nominees?


These women in my opinion are just as deserving and even more deserving! Glenn Close in my opinion should have won at least twice! She was majorly robbed for not winning for Fatal Attraction and Dangerous Liaisons! The same as Julianne Moore who has gotten overlooked for nominations as well as wins! When you look at the body of work with these ladies they are all are just as deserving and more so as Bening! Don’t get me wrong, I think Bening deserves and Oscar as well but she isn’t special! I think because she is married to a film legend people assume she is one to but she really isn’t! She really didn’t get noticed until Grifters and her own husband Warren Beatty has had 4 nominations for acting and 0 wins himself!

The truth is it isn’t the actors who are competing against each other it is the roles that they play. Portman’s role in Black Swan is way meatier and Oscar battier than anything this year and that is why she will win. Could an actress do what Portman did? Yes, but I don’t think many actors could do what Bening did in The Kids are Alright, but nobody cares about that movie as much as Portman’s Black Swan.

I am not saying she should win this year or ever, but the overdue thing is just not accurate.

Glenn Close (5 nominations, 0 wins)
Michelle Pfeiffer (3 nominations O wins)
Joan Allen (3 nominations 0 wins)
Julianne Moore (4 nominations 0 wins)
Laura Linney (3 nominations 0 wins)
Debra Winger (3 nomintations 0 wins)

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

She was not robbed for American Beauty! I hate when people say this because it is just a lie. They wanted to nominate her for supporting actor but instead they gambled on the fact the movie was so popular and placed her in the leading actress category. She was clearly not the star of that film and Thora Birch had more screen time than she did! Not to mention Hillary Swanks performance in Boys Don’t Cry was just totally ground breaking and perfect.

Like Portman’s role in Black Swan, The Boys Dont Cry role was also way meatier and complicated than the crazy housewife in American Beauty that frankly many could have played that character. Swanks performance in Boys Don’t Cry was raved and talked about for months before the Oscars came around. She deserved that Oscar! That was one of the best performances by an actor I have seen in a really long time.

reply