MovieChat Forums > Sean Young Discussion > In all seriousness: Mental illness or ju...

In all seriousness: Mental illness or just a miscreant.


there can be a fine line

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

Well, she does have some sort of drug addiction.

reply

We don't know if drug addiction was the cause of this or her previous high-jinx. I think the difference is that we don't expect this from a woman vs. a man so readily.

reply

And, the judgement of whether someone is mentally ill or not can be subjective.
In the 1980's msny Soviet dissidents were hospitalized with a diagnosis of creeping schizophrenia. The diagnosis was based largely on the philosophies, activism, and religosity of the dissidents. In a society that values conformity, dissent may be taken as psycho-pathology.

reply

well, it's not subjective if one has psychosis, or is emotionally disturbed enough to be dysfunctional

reply

<< And, the judgement of whether someone is mentally ill or not can be subjective. >>

Sometimes.

Frances Farmer wasn't really mentally ill, she was just a loud-mouthed drunk who didn't like to wear makeup.

In the 1930's, this constituted mental illness.

reply

'And, the judgement of whether someone is mentally ill or not can be subjective'.
-------------------
Not when you're a clinical narcissist. Then it becomes very objective

reply