Burt's Best Movie: The Longest Yard (SPOILERS)
Of all his hits, and his considerably fewer classics, I think The Longest Yard is the best Burt Reynolds movie.
As he said at the time, "the script didn't have Robert Redford and Paul Newman's fingerprints on it" -- it was brought to him first. Along with James Caan and Nick Nolte, he was about the only actor of his time who could play an NFL player (he'd been a college footballer), and the movie lets him play the first 20 minutes with long hair and a moustache(very cool) before sending him to prison and cutting off the stash and down the hair(he looks pretty brutal, primal -- his comedy chops shine through, but the character is a tough guy.)
The director was Robert Aldrich, who had had the hit The Dirty Dozen and here elaborated on that film's sequence in which convict GIs rout a bunch of regular Army guys in "War Games." Here its "the prisoners versus the guards" on the football field, and in its 70's way , the movie asks us to root for killers, rapists, and crooks as the GOOD GUYS versus sadistic, oppressive establishment guards. Burt was the key to making it work -- he was a NICE convict, a game-throwing self-loathing once-rich NFL superstar who gets thrown into prison with very financially poor men and has to earn everybody's respect.
I had three experiences seeing(or trying to see) The Longest Yard in '74 and '75.
First, I went out to see it on a Saturday night and...to my shock...all the night's showings were sold out. I told my companion...."A BURT REYNOLDS movie is sold out all night?" I sensed he might be a star after all.
Second, a few months later, I saw the film with about 1/3 of a house and I enjoyed it and I was gripped by it -- Eddie Albert's evil power-mad warden is a man you want to hate -- but there was little audience reaction.