MovieChat Forums > Cuba Gooding Jr. Discussion > Should he have won the Oscar?

Should he have won the Oscar?


List of nominees.

Cuba Gooding, Jr. – Jerry Maguire
William H. Macy – Fargo
Armin Mueller-Stahl – Shine
Edward Norton – Primal Fear
James Woods – Ghosts of Mississippi

Personal opinion is Macy should have won. Edward Norton was also very good in Primal Fear. Gooding for me seemed more like a nominee performance and not award winning.

reply

This message has been deleted by an administrator

reply

I'd have gone for Woods, but I don't think Cuba Gooding Jr should even have been nominated.

Thomas, if you is a mouse catcher, I is Lana Turner - which I ain't...

reply

I actually thought Edward Norton gave the best performance in Primal Fear. Surprised Tom Cruise wasn't even nominated. He was just as good in Jerry Maguire as Cuba Gooding Jr. It's hard for me to go against Cuba Gooding Jr. in the end because he seems like such a nice guy and I loved his acceptance speech. It's a shame what's become of his career. Now he only makes direct to video s***.

reply

Tom Cruise was nominated for best actor

reply

Yes. A women won a Oscar just for making a phone call. It is the performance that is memorable and that phrase Show Me the Money is all he needed. And you cannot compare because it is like comparing apple with oranges. Was his comedic performance better then Norton's dramatic one. IMO yes. I bet people today will remember his performance over anyone else that year. Ask a person in the street do they remember that line then ask them do they remember any line from any of his competitors that year or even what their roles were. The fact is IMO he was very good in that movie and was awarded accordingly.

reply

"Ask a person in the street do they remember that line then ask them do they remember any line from any of his competitors that year or even what their roles were."

People remember "I'll be back" but that doesn't make Schwarzenegger a great actor. Actually, Gooding's line is all that I remember from his performance. The classic scene on the phone. I loved the movie but I can't remember anything else that he did in it except that he played football. I remember Macy's performance better and Norton's is memorable only for the twist. At the time, there was a lot of good will about Jerry Maguire and Gooding and the line so that's why he won.

George Carlin: It's all bullsh-t and it's bad for ya.

reply

maybe another question should be,
should he have to give it back

reply

Why should he give the Oscar back.

Dustin Hoffman, De Niro and Barbara Streisand make the Fokker films these days, should they give their Oscars back!

Its that man again!!

reply