A lot of young women went through MGM from the 1920s through the 1950s, and the great majority of them did not end up deranged and dead in their forties. There was something mentally wrong with Garland in the first place.
She most likely was manic/depressive, and they didn't have the knowledge or medications to deal with it in those days.
Garland seemed to lack the ability to pull herself up by the bootstraps. Why, I don't know. (It's true that doing the same things over and over and expecting different results is akin to insanity.)
However, contributing to this was being robbed by husbands, managers, and trusting the wrong people. As a young person at MGM (where they got her hooked on uppers and downers), everything was done for her -- or she was TOLD what to do. The studio system was like a parent. (It's been written that her own mother had her on medications before MGM, or was a willing participant with MGM.)
In her formative years, I don't think she ever learned (or had to learn) how to be responsible in life. She was allowed to coast on her talent. She didn't seem to want to take responsibility, because she never really had to.
MGM was all-controlling. All her decisions were made for her. Maybe she liked it that way.
She never had a chance to learn the life skills that we all are faced with as teenagers and adolescents. (Handling money, for example. The money was always there -- till it wasn't!)
Even in her music, I get the impression that she didn't want to learn anything new, relying on the tried and true. Go through her discography, and how many times did she record the same songs? (She even joked in concert, about singing new material.) Yet, in her youth, they say she was a very quick study.
All very difficult to figure out. For one so gifted, it's beyond sad, the way she wound up.
reply
share