MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > The Magnificent Ambersons: rebirth for r...

The Magnificent Ambersons: rebirth for ruined Orson Welles masterpiece that rivalled Citizen Kane



The studio ‘butchered’ the legendary director’s 1942 film. Now an ambitious project is under way to restore it

The idea of deleting scenes from a film by renowned actor-director Orson Welles would be sacrilege today. But just after he made his masterpiece Citizen Kane for RKO in 1941, studio executives butchered his next great movie, The Magnificent Ambersons, burning extensive footage without consulting him.

Welles was so devastated that he later lamented: “They destroyed Ambersons and it destroyed me.”

Although the film is still considered a masterpiece and is admired for its visual creativity, expressionistic lighting and complex camera angles, Welles had intended a dark story about the demise of a wealthy family in the early 20th century. But RKO cut about 45 minutes, deleting some of the more “downbeat” scenes and giving it a happy ending.

Now a US film-maker has almost completed an ambitious project to recreate Welles’s original vision for the film, which starred Joseph Cotten, who also appeared in Citizen Kane and with whom Welles went on to make The Third Man in 1949.

Brian Rose has used the latest technology to reconstruct lost material and animate charcoal sketches that prompt the viewer’s imagination into visualising what Welles once saw: “The few who saw his original version believed it was the greatest film they had ever seen.”
...
https://www.theguardian.com/film/2023/jun/18/magnificent-ambersons-rebirth-for-ruined-orson-welles-masterpiece-that-rivalled-citizen-kane

reply

I'm waiting for the real breakthrough; reanimating Kafka so that he completes one freaking book so that Wells (who also has been revived), completes his movie of the same name, The Trial.

reply

I thought 'The Castle' was hysterical.

Unbelievable that RKO actually burned the cuttings.

reply

No wonder RKO is not a thing now.

reply

They've recreated a couple of old lost and partially lost "Doctor Who" episodes this way, replacing lost scenes or scenes which only have a soundtrack left with cheap animation. FYI the results are... only of interest to serious fans.


I mean it certainly sounds like an interesting project for some film student or wannabe director, but don't expect an actual lost masterpiece.

reply

I saw it maybe 15 years ago and thought it was all over the place. Maybe this restored version can do it justice.

reply

Evidently they mangled the shit out of it, changed the ending radically. The original uncut version, clearly intended as an epic, was cut from 132 to 88 minutes. Clearly an adult drama, the test audience were primarily teen-agers. Coming out right after the war started, probably not a great tone match to the times. Clearly a perfect storm of creative vandalism.

Remember, this is Wells at the top of his game.

reply

Wow, that's quite the cut. I'm debating whether I would watch this new version as Welles had no say in it.

reply