MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > More trite Christmas music

More trite Christmas music




We have so much shit music dumped on us during this time of year. Jingle Bell Rock and Rock’in’ Around The Christmas Tree, both by Brenda Lee, if my memory serves me. Who the FUCK wants to tolerate these chestnuts any longer? How about I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Clause? I suppose it’s better than I Saw Mommy Blowing Santa Clause, but the melody and lyrics still, uh, suck. There’s The Beach Boy’s feckless lunge at Christmas music, Run, Run, Roodolph, which went the way of The Third Reich. Then we have the grandaddy of ‘em all, White Christmas, by Irving Berlin, from his Broadway show, Holiday Inn. Every songsmith on the face of the earth would KILL to come up with another White Christmas, because it’s a fucking gold mine of royalties. So, brace yourself for hearing it repeatedly over the next few days.

My belabored point is that Christmas is sacred, not secular. Pop music has no place in Christmas, no more than Black Friday, Instacart and DoorDash do. Do you think DoorDash gets to your home faster than Santa? Does your Dasher place a finger aside of his nose, and up the chimney s/he rose?

You’re lucky if your fucking Dasher even personally hands you your delivery. Your food is sitting at your front door with a DoorDash bag that tells all homeless folks, “Hey! Free food here!”

Have yourself a merry little Christmas.

reply

I agree with a lot of the original post. It does amaze me as to how much Christmas music out there is "forgettable." And, as a Christian, my favorite Christmas carols are the ones that have Christ as the subject ("Silent Night" is probably my favorite...I also love "O Holy Night, "Away In A Manger," "The First Noel," "What Child Is This?"/"Greensleves," et.al.).

There are two secular Christmas songs that I really love and I'd like to explain why I think they're so great:

1) "The Christmas Song"--1961 recording by Nat King Cole. The last time Cole recorded this song and I think he really nailed this one. I love the guitar playing and piano playing on this song. This really has such an interesting chord progression...very "jazzy" and just so well done.

2) "I Believe In Father Christmas"--Greg Lake. I have a "guitar player's ear" and I just love the opening 12-string. It's an incredible song, IMO...but especially the version with the orchestral ending. Lake co-wrote this song with Pete Sinfield. About 20 years ago, I had a buddy on a guitar website who e-mailed Sinfield about this song and Sinfield actually responded back. He said a big part of the inspiration of this song was the "So This Is Christmas" line from John Lennon. He went on to say that Greg Lake didn't have the greatest childhood and a lot of this song came from Lake's background. It's such a masterful composition. I sure do miss Greg Lake.

I do love to listen to the "classic crooners" when it comes to Christmas music...Nat King Cole, Bing Crosby, Perry Como, Andy Williams, et.al. Someone else who had a great Christmas recording that one might not expect is John Tesh...I loved his "A Romantic Christmas" recording that came out around 30 years ago (I can't believe it's that old now). But I've had the "Christmas Blues" a couple of times in my life and it's no fun, so I definitely get the sentiment here.

reply

There you go: -
https://moviechat.org/general/General-Discussion/61ac0268d00bd7266405fb76/Post-a-Christmas-song

reply

Thank you...and, yes, I am really enjoying this thread! Thank you for posting that...I've heard most of them before, but some I haven't!

reply

It gets recycled every year. I have a humongous record collection and like think that I have an encyclopaedic knowledge of music and yet there’s loads I don’t know 🎼🎶🎵🎹🎤🥁🎻🎺🎷🪗🪕🪘🎸🤘

reply