MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Top 25 Movies Statistically Speaking

Top 25 Movies Statistically Speaking


Statisics used: Critic reviews, audience reviews, box office results, awards - 36,842 movies ranked this was the Top 25

1. Lawrence of Arabia (1962)
2. The Godfather (1972)
3. Gone with the Wind (1939)
4. Schindler's List (1993)
5. On the Waterfront (1954)
6. Ben-Hur (1959)
7. Casablanca (1942)
8. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
9. The Godfather: Part II (1974)
10. One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (1975)
11. The Best Years of Our Lives (1946)
12. The Apartment (1960)
13. The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957)
14. Platoon (1986)
15. It Happened One Night (1934)
16. American Beauty (1999)
17. Patton (1970)
18. Unforgiven (1992)
19. The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
20. Amadeus (1984)
21. Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope (1977)
22. Rebecca (1940)
23. Forrest Gump (1994)
24.Terms of Endearment (1983)
25. Saving Private Ryan (1998)

reply

What formula was used? You would think that The Dark Knight was somewhere up there if audience reviews, box office numbers, and all that stuff came into play.

reply

47% reviews....35% box office......18% awards (Oscars/GoldenGlobes)

The Dark Knight currently sits in 205th place....ahead of 36,637 movies.

reply

Huh, I thought it'd be a lot higher

reply

It's infamous Oscar snub for Best Picture hurt the movie's score. Too bad "Most Popular Movie" was not an Oscar category decade ago....has it really been 10 years since The Dark Knight?

Dark Knight stats from our database (out of 36,842 movies)

35th biggest domestic box office hit of all-time (using adjusted grosses)

50th biggest worldwide box office hit of all-time (using adjusted grosses)

36th best reviewed movie of all-time (critics and audiences).....has not been updated lately

reply

[deleted]

The basis of our ranking system is what a person wants to accomplish if they produced a movie. The first thing they would want would be for the movie to be successful at the box office. Secondly, they would like the critics AND moviegoers to enjoy their movie. And finally they would like their movie to receive award recognition through Golden Globe® and Oscar® ceremonies at the end of the year. Over the years we have tweaked our forumla....and have over the years de-emphasized the box office...and increased the review %.

So a movie like Minions killed at the box....got no love....and received lukewarm reviews sits in 3,278th place while The Revenant....was a box office hit......was loved by critics.....liked by audiences....and won some major Oscars....so it sits in 219th place.

Our rankings are not perfect, but when he look at individual performers....it does make the cream rise to the top. Currently we are read in 240 countries.

reply

Ranking movies without any categories is ridiculous.

What if we rank best cars without categories, which one is best Lamborghini Countach or Rolls Royce Phantom?

How is Schindler's List better than Star Wars IV? How is Ben-Hur better than American Beauty? Totally different kind of movies.

You can basically shuffle this list randomly and still kinda makes sense. I would put Saving Private Ryan in like #17, and Platoon in #21, while Lawrence of Arabia at #5. Still a legit list.

reply

Hey actionkamen.....the category is "Statistically Speaking"....so it was ranked by the stats of the movie. From Lawrence of Arabia to Kirk Cameron's Saving Christmas (our lowest rated movie).

As for the differences....most of the top movies were box office smashes....so they max out the box office point category.....reviews are different for every movie.....and the reviews are from "professional" and "amateur" critics....so it causes a difference between Ben-Hur and American Beauty when looking at a movie "statistically"

The Top 10 are actually pretty much tied with a perfect score of 100 in our system....10 movies out of close to 37,000 movies....not too bad.

reply

I like this list. Looks like it was compiled by a mature adult. There's always something to quibble about, the good ol' "your results may vary" thing, but this looks like a fair list in my eyes.

reply

Hey snepts....I like to think we are mature adults....we started doing these rankings in 2011.....and our website has grown very nicely over the years. You are so right.....like any list.....they are made to be argued with ....lol......so indeed "your results my vary".

reply

Wow, not a one of my top 5 are on that list, but then I only use my own very personal statistics 😄

reply

Thanks for checking out my Top 25 Statistically Speaking.

reply

What, no Ghoulies?

reply

Hey Moonglum....Ghoulies just missed the Top25....only missing it by 21,207 spots.

reply

Cosmically speaking, that's not a lot! Go Ghoulies! Your day will come!

reply

Yep....knocking on the door of the Top 25.

reply

Where does The Room rate ??

reply

Hey hownos....The Room sits in 35,659 place in our database. Means 1,273 movies are ranked worse in our database. Over the last few years it's review approval from audiences has actually risen dramatically....still rated a bad movie....but it used to be rated a horrible movie. On a scale of 0 (lowest) to 100 (highest).....The Room has a Ultimate Movie Ranking (UMR) score of 3.21. Before the audience reviews increased so much it was under 1.00. I guess the power of playing football in tuxedos is catching on.

reply