MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Overrated masterpieces

Overrated masterpieces


Who do you think are some overrated 'masterpiece' films? I would say Citizen Kane, E.T, Interstellar, Avatar,

reply

Mulholland Drive and The Dark Knight

reply

Oh my goodness. I was thinking the same. I tried really hard to see what others saw, but I just didn't get it.

reply

I know right?? I went to go see The Dark Knight with 2 friends and no lie, we ALL fell asleep!! I woke up and looked at them and they were asleep too. I couldn't believe it!! When they woke up we were all like come on, let's just go. So we all left like halfway through the movie. And as far as Mulholland Drive, well, yeah, I just didn't get it either and had no inclination to even want to get it lol. I couldn't wait for it to be over!!

reply

-

reply

I hope so! Seems like it's shaping up to be just that :)

reply

Amen...

reply

9, what the hell is up with all your posts? They've all disappeared!! Did you quit us? Did you get booted???? What's up?

reply

Hey April, no no, I'm here but can't come on as much for a while. We don't have a lot of settings for our accounts yet so this was the best I could do. Be back with the MC fam later. 😎

reply

So you deleted ALL your posts/comments?!?!

reply

Wow, this is so strange.. 9 is (was?) probably the most active and positive user since the beginning here. And now ALL his/hers threads and posts are deleted - by himself!?! And not seen since 5 days. This is a mystery worthy of Sherlock Holmes.

reply

Seems to me they wanted to deactivate their account for some reason but was unable to so they edited all their posts. Hope all is well though.

reply

But why deactivate the account? 9 seemed extremely interested in forum here doing good. Deleting over 1200 posts, all of them good contributions to the board, is doing the complete opposite. It leaves hundreds of discussions with big gaps.

Yeah, hope all is well with him/her.

reply

[deleted]

πŸ˜‰πŸ˜‰πŸ˜‰πŸ˜‰πŸ˜ŠπŸ˜ŠπŸ˜ŠπŸ˜Š

reply

9

reply

[deleted]

Titanic...great film! Didn't care much for the other two though.

reply

I love Avatar. The story in and of itself is nothing new. But man was that an extremely well made film!!

reply


Yes, Avatar had great special effects but the story was stolen from the 1992 animated film Ferngully: The Last Rainforest and Dances With Wolves.

reply

Yeah and from American history too....

reply


I liked Lost in Translation, but YES to Titantic and Avatar being overrated, especially Avatar. I hated that film!

reply

[deleted]

I'm not a big fan of either of those, but I especially agree about Avatar. You can't deny it's responsible for the current 3D boom (for better or worse), so it's influential in some ways. But take away the effects and it's nothing that special, storywise.

reply

Gravity - I thought it was awful.

reply

[deleted]


I wouldn't say it was bad, just mediocre.

reply

[deleted]


I agree on both counts, Dazed. 😎

reply

Couldnt agree more. Terribly overrated

reply

Blow-Up, La Dolce Vita and Easy Rider are all overrated in my opinion.

reply

OMG Easy Rider you say??!! No no!

reply

Agree.. Just no no no!

reply

2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)

That movie was so slow running I would rather watch paint dry.

reply

Really Sandman! Gee whiz , I have to disagree with you on that one. It still gives me chills to this day and I say it in the theatre all those years ago.

reply

The Shining, hate that flick

reply

In my opinion, The Shining is one of the best films in the horror genre, largely due to its eerie atmosphere, richly textured backdrops, hallucinatory scenes, graphic images which are just as much about art and style as they are about the violence which they depict, and ultimately, the way Kubrick makes mundane, harmless images, such a boy riding a tricycle down a hallway generate so much suspense, hitting very close to home as he makes such normal everyday things and occurrences appear so surreal, realistic and at the same time, downright scary when he so chooses to. Most of the great horror films such as Psycho and The Exorcist employ the same techniques. Not sure why many consider Kubrick's films, even his best, to be overrated since I consider him to be one of the greatest directors of all time.

reply

The opening scene alone is worth an Oscar (if they had Oscars for that LOL). The striking visuals and the unbelievably eerie music make for the best and scariest/creepiest movie beginnings I've ever seen!!!! Both gorgeous and fear inducing at the same time!! 😱😱😱😱

reply

The irony is that Kubrick wasn't even on location when they filmed the opening scene, yet I'm pretty sure it was his idea to shoot aerial footage of Glacier National Park in Montana and use it for the opening credits since it was consistent with the rest of the film. Describing this scene as "gorgeous and fear inducing at the same time" is the perfect way to put it, for it foreshadowed what was in store, as the rest of the film's visually arresting scenes suggested normalcy yet were simultaneously coupled with unexplained oddities--for after all this film involved supernatural elements along with a main character who had a few screws lose. And then there was the sexual undertones in this film, such as the man in the bear costume which some say was a visual motif for incest, along with supposed political undertones which have led some to speculate about conspiracy theories involving this film. And then you have Kubrick's strict attention to detail--taking 5 years to make this film, not to mention reshooting scenes multiple times, most notably Shelly Duvall's scene showing her trying to hit Jack Nicholson's character with a baseball bat, had 127 takes. Being more specific about this film's backdrop, the interior of The Overlook Hotel, was comprised of grand ballrooms, enormous lobbies and a seemingly endless maze of corridors, which couldn't possibly fit in a hotel of this size judging by the size of the exterior, which was done intentionally to play tricks on the subconscious mind of a viewer. Perhaps all that needs to be said is, before David Lynch rose to prominence, there was Stanley Kubrick.

reply

I guess I never did fall under Kubrick's spell then, because I've never been able to finish watching it from start to finish, although I do love attention to detail. Nor am I Lynch fan.

I did like the build-up of suspense -- to a point. The location and shots of it were great, and the slowly increasing sense of paranoia fueled by isolation. But after that, meh.

reply

I agree. The imagery in The Shining is stunning.

reply

To paraphrase what I was telling April, the reason why The Shining was so visually arresting was because Kubrick was a master of focusing on a simple mundane object, putting it on a pedestal in such a way that it becomes so important that the viewer becomes fascinated with it, which is pretty much what an artist aspires to do. Once Kubrick has a viewer under his hypnotic control with his artistic vision, he can pretty much toy with you any way he chooses, which in a horror film can be downright scary to experience.

reply

I'm also un-blown away by ON THE WATERFRONT. It's fine, and the acting's definitely good, I just have no desire to ever see it a second time.

reply