MovieChat Forums > 3D Films > I've seen THE HOBBIT 3, and I have to wa...

I've seen THE HOBBIT 3, and I have to warn you something.


First off all, I will only include general spoilers. By that I mean that I won't say anything you haven't figured out after watching the trailer and/or the previous 5 movies (this is a prequel after all, so you know which characters won't die).

The journey in L.O.T.R. was to basically save the world. The journey in THE HOBBIT isn't. Our heroes win the war of the title but it doesn't affect the Middle Earth that much. At least in comparison to SAURON's death. It ends with BILBO going back home and then it ties in with the beginning of FELLOWSHIP. Not exactly something that will you make you cry.

Therefore, when you go see this movie, don't expect the emotional impact and depth from RETURN OF THE KING. If you do, you'll feel empty. If you don't, you'll feel like you've seen a not-life-changing but fun adventure.

Also, remember that FRODO & BILBO were given different tasks. Neither of them fights in battles for the most part, but FRODO exhausted all of his energy ir order to do the thing that actually defeated the villain. BILBO was never meant to do any of that. If you don't keep this in mind, you might be frustrated due to BILBO's lack of duties and/or screen time (the lack is almost as big as in DESOLATION).

reply

So, like the book but longer.

"Make me a baby!
Make me a star!
Leave my coffin slightly ajar!"
- Lesley Gore

reply

No sh!t, Sherlock!

And I have to say, I felt more emotional impact from the (made up) love story of Tauriel and Kili than from Return of the King...



--
No, Schmuck! You are only entitled to your INFORMED opinion!!
-- Harlan Ellison

reply

No sh!t, Sherlock!
Calm down. I wrote it when it came out here (a week before the U.S.).

reply

i just got my 3d blu-ray print.I liked the ending.It ended the way it started and the wizard makes a surprise visit.i thought i was going nut's ,but, the good guys doing was sad and made me cry.There was a romantic development between the elf women and the dwarf who died. It made me cry .I was crying in the ending.did they do this purposely - the film makers ?I wonder? I'm sure the actors and technicians were in tears when they would have to go there separate ways ,since they been together so long for this film.this was done in one big studio in New Zealand

reply